baby shower cake ideas
Entertainment, Parenting

Baby Shower Cake Ideas: 25 Creative Options to Consider

Whether you’re a fan of parties or not, you can’t deny that the cake is the best part of any social gathering. And baby showers are no different. A good cake is a perfect way to close an amazing celebration of the future parents and their bundle of joy!

But, the key to a good baby shower cake isn’t just about picking the right design — it’s also about choosing a flavor the future mom and her guests will love. So to help make your baby shower a touch sweeter, here are the most creative baby shower cake ideas to delight your taste buds!

Baby Shower Planning 101

Baby Shower

Image source: Pinterest

Baby showers are a staple in many anglophone countries like the US, the UK, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand. They date back to the 1950s baby boom, and their purpose is to celebrate the future mom’s pregnancy, as well as gift her with much-needed baby items. Because they center the new mom, it’s standard practice to have close family and friends plan it.

While this is a great honor, it’s also a huge responsibility. Like any party, there are several key components to a successful baby shower, such as budget, venue, theme, party games, and food.

1. Budget

Before doing anything else, you first need to outline your budget. It may be annoying, but money plays a crucial role in party planning, and baby showers can rack up a pretty impressive bill.

Between the venue, the food, the decorations, and party favors, you’re looking at an average cost of $100 to a whopping $1,500! So, to prevent overspending, it’s crucial you put on paper exactly what you can and can’t afford.

2. Venue

You can’t have a party without a suitable place to host it. Therefore, after outlining your budget, the next thing you should do is choose a venue. The kind of venue you go for will largely depend on the type of party you want to hold.

For example, it’s tradition to host baby showers in someone’s home. It’s a spacious and completely free locale that can handle most themes. Consequently, it’s a no-brainer if you’re strapped for cash.

However, if your budget can handle renting a space, then you can also host your shower at the future mom’s favorite restaurant. Depending on the type of locale and the number of guests, this option can be just as budget-friendly, particularly if your house can’t handle a lot of guests.

But, if you have a little extra money to splurge, you can always go for a fancier venue. Vineyards, country clubs, or art galleries are the perfect locations for a classier, high-end event. But take care! These locales can be anywhere between $500 and $1,500 to rent. So only go for them if your gathering is 60+ guests and you’re absolutely certain you have enough money.

3. The Theme

If you ask anyone what’s the most memorable part of a baby shower, the likely answer will be the theme! The right theme is what helps you generate a fun atmosphere that is sure to delight your guests and the future mom alike. However, just going with the first visually appealing idea you saw on your Pinterest feed won’t cut it.

You have to consider the soon-to-be mom’s tastes. Baby shower themes usually center on the parents’ hobbies or interests. So if the expecting mom is a fan of Star Wars, you can center the baby shower around George Lucas’ space opera.

However, you shouldn’t just go with a theme the new mom will like. You also have to make sure the theme fits with your choice of venue and budget. For example, it would make the most sense to host a nature-inspired party at an outdoor venue, like someone’s backyard or the local park.

In contrast, a theme centered around reading and books is better suited for a low-key indoor place such as a house or a library.

4. The Food

Before the desserts come the main course. To be fair, you don’t exactly have to serve Michelin star dishes at your party. However, you do have to provide your guests with something to munch on.

When creating your menu, choose dishes you know everyone will be able to eat. Finger sandwiches, quiche bites, spring rolls or chips, and salsa are usually a safe choice for a party because you can personalize them to fit your theme and your guests’ food intolerances. However, if your budget allows for a bit of creativity, you can diversify your menu.

For example, you can go with some miniature versions of everyone’s favorite comfort foods. Dishes such as mini mac and cheese bowls, hamburger sliders, pancake cereal, or bite-sized waffles not only look adorable but are sure to impress any crowd. If something fancier is more your style, feel free to include a charcuterie board or an omelet station.

How to Pick the Right Cake


Image source: Pinterest

After picking the location, the theme, and your appetizers, the last thing you have to take care of is the cake. And this is no easy feat.

One big mistake many make when choosing their cake is focusing solely on aesthetics. That is somewhat understandable because the cake’s appearance is a big part of the baby shower theme.

However, as the old saying goes, looks aren’t everything.

When it comes to desserts, taste matters just as much. Therefore, when choosing your cake, here are a few things to keep in mind.

1. Pick a Flavor for the Mom-to-be, Not Yourself

It’s a bit redundant to point out that a baby shower is an event centered around the future mom and her baby. However, in the chaos of planning, it’s easy to lose sight of the future mom’s preferences.

For starters, pregnancy greatly impacts a person’s hormone levels. It also increases the mother’s metabolic rate, prompting the body to burn more energy to keep itself and the child sustained. All this results in increased hunger and pregnancy cravings.

Around 50% to 90% of pregnant people report experiencing cravings for specific foods or strange food combinations. One of the most common pregnancy cravings is for sweets and refined carbohydrates. This is great news since the cake is the king of sugary carbs!

But be aware. As common as food cravings are, food aversions are equally as prevalent. During the first trimester, there is an increase in the human chorionic gonadotropin hormone or HGC. Doctors theorize this hormone makes pregnant people particularly sensitive to certain tastes, smells, and textures.

Foods like eggs, onions, dairy products, and garlic commonly trigger nausea. Since most cakes contain both dairy and eggs, this may present an issue. Hence, it’s important to consult with the mother before picking out the cake to see if she can eat it.

If the idea of a creamy custard cake makes the future mom gag, you can always swap it for another treat. Giant donuts, jumbo cinnamon rolls, or skillet cookies are all viable alternatives for large-scale gatherings. These treats are not only fun to look at, but they’re the perfect way to satisfy the future mom’s taste buds!

2. Be Mindful of Food Restrictions

When ordering your desserts, remember that the future mom may not be the only one with food restrictions. Whether it’s a food allergy, a new diet regimen, or a moral stance, over 60% of Americans report having at least one kind of dietary restriction.

For many, this means monitoring their intake of unhealthy foods, like added salt or refined sugar. But for others, food restrictions entail cutting out entire food groups. For example, over 1.62 million people in the US are vegan. Therefore, they completely avoid consuming animal products, such as meat, dairy, eggs, or fish.

On the other side of the spectrum, around 6% of people follow a low carb or keto diet. Their diet limits not just the consumption of refined carbs, but all carbohydrates, including whole grains, fruits, and starchy vegetables. An increasing number of people also avoid gluten, dairy, and nuts, either because of an intolerance or a severe allergy.

All this is to say that you have a lot of restrictions to work around when picking out a cake. Fortunately, you won’t have to wrack your brain too much to come up with a solution. Most bakeries will custom-make cakes that comply with a wide range of dietary restrictions.

And even if you can’t find a cake that will fit everyone’s preferences, you can always opt for separate desserts. To be fair, this may end up costing a bit more, but if you have extra cash, why not spend it on something your friend will love!

3. Size Up!

The last thing to consider is cake size. The cake diameter will depend on how many guests you’re planning to invite to the shower. The average slice is around 2 inches long, 4 inches tall, and 1 inch wide. So a bit of math reveals that your standard 8-inch cake will serve around 20‒30 people.

However, if you plan on having more than 30 guests, then you may have to size up the cake to 10 inches. Another important thing to keep in mind is the cake shape. Overall, round cakes provide fewer servings than square cakes, even if they’re the same size. For example, a 10 inch round cake yields around 38 servings. In contrast, a 10-inch square cake will yield around 50.

Consequently, if the cake’s shape doesn’t matter much to you, going with a square cake may be the better option. But if the mom-to-be insists on a round cake, you can also go with a tiered cake. As their name suggests, tiered cakes consist of multiple smaller cakes stacked on top of each other in order of size.

While gigantic tiered cakes are a staple at weddings, smaller ones can also work for other social events like a baby shower. A two-tier 8×10 inch cake can feed between 30 and 60 people, which is great for a medium-sized gathering. Plus, it looks incredible, especially if you add the right decor to it.

25 Baby Shower Cake Ideas

Now that you know the basics of picking a cake for your baby shower, it’s finally time to get to the cakes themselves. Usually, the overall design of the cake is supposed to relate to the baby shower theme.

However, this isn’t a strict rule. The cake can also reflect other things relating to a mom and her baby, like the little one’s gender or the mom’s personal preferences. Alternatively, you can also use the cake as inspiration to pick a theme if you don’t have one already. Either way, these 25 incredible baby shower cake ideas are sure to get your creative juices flowing!

1. Baby on a Moon


Image source: Pinterest

Is there anything more traditional than a baby cake for a baby shower? How about a baby sleeping on a moon! This beautiful combination is the ideal baby shower cake for a very low-key event between close family and friends. Plus, the baby theme is simple enough to allow for some customization.

For example, if the future mom is expecting a boy, you can use a silver-blue color scheme to reflect that. You can also add some fondant stars to the sides and coat them with sparkling cake spray. That way, the cake will glow like the brightest stars in the sky!

2. Balloon Cake


Image source: Pinterest

A simple tiered cake with balloon decorations is like a blank canvass you can repurpose to fit any theme. For example, if the future mom knows the gender of her baby, then you can add different colors to the cake to reflect that. Pink or peach-colored balloons for a girl are a classic, while blue or green shades work best if it’s a boy.

When it comes to decorations, you can use edible balloon stickers to make the cake visually appealing. However, for a bigger pop, you can make the balloons out of fondant instead. Afterward, stack them on the top tier to give off the 3D illusion that they’re about to flow away. In terms of cake designs, it doesn’t get easier or more magical than this!

3. Kitty Cake


Image source: Pinterest

There’s an old joke that the internet was invented so that we could share cat videos. This may be hyperbole, but you can’t deny that adding cats to literally anything makes it 100% better. And baby shower cakes are no exception.

A round cake shaped like a giant cat head is the backbone of a cat-inspired baby shower theme. Admittedly, this theme isn’t quite as gender-neutral as others on this list. However, if the mom-to-be is expecting a beautiful baby girl, it’s definitely a solid option!

4. Honeycomb Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Honeycombs and bees are a classic theme that works especially well if you’re baking the cake yourself and want something that’s fairly easy to put together. Though the outer honeycomb layer looks complicated to make, it actually requires two simple ingredients — yellow marzipan and bubble wrap.

Simply roll out your marzipan into a thin sheet, and then gently place some bubble wrap on top. Add some weight to it, let it rest for a few minutes, and voila! The bubble wrap will leave small indentations in the marzipan that will be reminiscent of a honeycomb.

Once you’ve wrapped the honeycomb sheet around the base, you can use the leftover marzipan to craft a few bees to add to the top. The whole process should take you a couple of hours, and you can even do it with a boxed cake mix!

5. Macaroons Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Can you think of anything more delicious than a box of macaroons? How about an entire macaroon cake! This baby shower cake idea is heavenly if the mom-to-be is a fan of these decadent French cookies. Plus, you can incorporate it into any baby shower theme, especially if you modify it with some colors and other cake decorations.

But be warned. Macaroons are notoriously difficult to make. Therefore, it’s not surprising that they pack a hefty price tag. So this cake may end up costing you a bit more than any other flavor, especially if you plan to add plenty of macaroons to the top tier.

6. Gender Reveal Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Traditionally, gender reveal parties are something parents host independently of a baby shower. However, it’s also not unheard of to have expecting mothers to use a baby shower to reveal the gender of their little one to close family and friends. If the mom-to-be plans to go down this route, then you have the perfect excuse to order a gender reveal cake for her baby shower.

In simple terms, a gender reveal cake is any type of cake you add gender signifiers to. So, for example, you take a basic vanilla cake and color the cake sponge pink. Therefore, when the mom cuts the cake, the layers are revealed, and the guests get to find out the mom is expecting a baby girl! It’s a two for one special your guests will never forget!

7. Gender Reveal Cake with Sprinkles


Image source: Pinterest

So, the expecting mom is set on a gender reveal cake for her baby shower. However, she thinks using dyed cake sponges is a bit uninspiring. In that case, why not go with a gender reveal cake with sprinkles!

This incredible baby shower cake also contains a surprise gender reveal when you cut into it. However, instead of plain ol’ dyed cake sponges, this cake is loaded with colorful sprinkles! When making this cake, bakers remove the center from each sponge, so when they stack the layers, they get a hollowed tube.

They then fill up that center with sprinkles. Consequently, when the mom moves to cut the cake, the sprinkles explode out, thus revealing the gender of her little one!

8. Donut Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Another gender reveal cake, but this time with a doughy twist! Donuts are one of America’s favorite comfort foods. Therefore, they make the perfect addition to any baby shower cake, especially if you’re going for a candy theme for your party.

To add the gender reveal spin, you can dye the donut glaze pink or blue. Another option would be to shape your cake to resemble a giant donut and add food coloring to the cake sponge for a surprise reveal.

9. Princess Cake


Image source: Pinterest

There is nothing more stereotypical than a princess-themed cake for a baby girl. However, there is a reason so many moms-to-be choose this particular cake idea for their party. It just looks incredible!

Plus, it’s one of those baby shower cake ideas that work well with any girly party theme, particularly Disney princess-related ones. For a low-key gathering, you can keep the cake fairly simple by making it one tier and adding a crown on top. But for a larger event, you can also get creative and play with a plethora of colors and textures so that your cake ends up resembling a real princess in a dress!

10. Blueberry White Cake


Image source: Pinterest

A baby shower doesn’t always have to involve pastel colors, balloons, and sprinkles. If the mom is in the mood for something on the down-low, a boho-style theme or backyard BBQ parties are also viable options. And to go along with the cozy atmosphere, you can serve the guests some blueberry white cake!

This cake flavor is about as American as apple pie. Plus, it has a very rustic look since it’s standard practice to leave the sides unfrosted. All in all, it’s a cake that will fit right into an intimate baby shower between close family and friends.

11. Stroller Cake


Image source: Pinterest

A stroller cake is another on-the-nose baby shower cake idea. However, the cuteness factor is strong enough to make up for the lack of originality. Like the macaroon or balloon cake, a stroller cake can fit well with any party theme. Furthermore, it’s completely gender-neutral, so it can work for boys and girls.

12. Flower Pot Cake

Flower Pot

Image source: Pinterest

If you’re planning a nature-inspired event, then this baby shower cake idea is a no-brainer. A cake shaped like a giant flower pot will delight any future mom with a green thumb.

What’s more, it’s a cake idea that allows for plenty of customizations. If your shower centers around gardening, then you can add some gardening tools on top or around the cake for an extra flare. However, if the cake theme is just flowers, then you can fill up the pot with edible versions of the mom’s favorite blossoms.

13. Bow Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Sometimes the simplest baby shower cake ideas are the best ones. And it doesn’t get much simpler than a single-tier bow cake. Like the princess cake, this design matches up beautifully with most girly themes. Furthermore, you can customize it however you like.

The most common option is to add the bow on top of the cake, to make it look like a giant present. However, you can spice things up by wrapping the bow around the base and coating the cake with a glittery finish!

14. Lotus Cake


Image source: Pinterest

In Buddhism, lotus flowers symbolize purity, faithfulness, and spiritual awakenings. Therefore, a cake decorated with a few lotus buds is a great option if the future mom is in tune with her spirituality. You can even add a breathtaking mirror glaze to give off the illusion that the lotus is floating on water!

15. Unicorn Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Unicorns are one of the most universally beloved fictional creatures out there. They’re synonymous with innocence, magic, and fairytales — the top three ingredients you need to assemble the ultimate baby shower cake! To make the unicorn pop out, opt for a double or triple-tier cake and add the unicorn design to the front.

If your baby shower theme centers around magic, you can add some additional decor to the cake, like rainbows or flowers. You can even play around with glitter and edible cake spray to make your cake shine like the mythical being that inspired it!

16. Flamingo Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Do you know what’s so great about flamingos? They’re just as beautiful and magical as unicorns. However, unlike unicorns, they actually exist! A pink flamingo cake is a lovely addition to any girly baby shower theme.

To make the cake simple, stick with a basic white and pink color scheme, and keep the flamingo as a centerpiece. However, for a more dramatic pop, you can add gold and black stripes and candied pineapple for that nice, tropical finish.

17. Rainbow Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Rainbows and baby showers go together like bread and butter. Not only do they add a splash of color to the event, but they also symbolize happiness. But beyond the positive connotations, there’s another reason to pick a rainbow cake for your party.

A rainbow baby is a term used to describe any healthy child born after a miscarriage. So, a rainbow cake is an obvious choice for any mom who has had fertility issues in the past. It not only looks beautiful, but it represents a precious blessing she received after a heartbreaking tragedy.

18. Bambi Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Is the mom-to-be a fan of Disney classics? In that case, you absolutely can’t go wrong with a Bambi cake. This baby shower cake idea pairs beautifully with a Disney-themed party or a general nature-inspired event. To emphasize the mother-child bond, you can throw in a doe cake topper to accompany the Bambi figurine.

19. Lamb Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Artists and poets often used lambs in their works to symbolize innocence and purity and, by extension, young children. Therefore, it’s not surprising that lambs are such a common baby shower theme.

Moreover, a lamb cake is pretty gender-neutral and can work with any party theme.

To be fair, it isn’t exactly the most creative baby shower cake idea. Nonetheless, it’s a solid option if the mom-to-be wants something minimalist for her party.

20. Bunny Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Who doesn’t love a good, fluffy bunny? Similar to cats, these adorable creatures make an inspiring baby shower theme and an even better baby shower cake. You can either shape the entire cake to resemble a bunny head or add some bunny motifs on top. All in all, it’s a cake fitting for all types of showers, especially ones that take place close to Easter.

21. Car Cake


Image source: Pinterest

A baby shower cake idea worthy of any strong baby boy! A car cake is great because of the numerous ways you can customize it. For a more intimate gathering, you can use a basic square cake with a checkered pattern to evoke a race track. However, if you want something more complex, you can always go for a multi-tier cake and make one tier into a small car.

22. Nautical Cake


Image source: Pinterest

Does the mom-to-be serve in the navy? Well, in that case, what better way to honor her, and her future sailor than with a nautical cake! Like the pink princess cake, this option is better suited to a baby boy than a girl.

It usually involves a navy blue and white color scheme, sailboat decorations, anchor stickers, and maybe a few edible marine animals for good measure. In short, it’s the best way to prepare the little one for his sea-faring adventure!

23. Tuxedo Cake


Image source: Pinterest

The male counterpart of the bow cake, a tuxedo cake, is ideal for a boy’s baby shower. You can stick with a basic white and black color scheme or diversify it with a splash of pastel blue. To make the cake resemble an actual tuxedo, you can add a few fondant buttons or even an edible mustache!

24. Baby Chick Cake


Image source: Pinterest

When you think of symbols of motherhood, you likely think of a mother bird and her chick. So it makes sense to use this motif as inspiration for your baby shower cake. You can incorporate it into a woodland theme or a basic animal kingdom-style party. It’s simple, adorable, and goes well with outdoor and indoor parties.

25. Baby Booties Cake


Image source: Pinterest

There is nothing quite so precious as a pair of baby booties. Therefore, why not use them as a theme for your baby shower cake? You can either make the cake into a pair of baby booties or use them as a cake topper. And the best part is that the booties are gender-neutral. Consequently, they can symbolize both a baby boy and a baby girl!

Previous Post Next Post

You Might Also Like